Using social media to grow your nonprofit can feel like an unending task, but it doesn't have to be. With a clear strategy, you can turn your social channels into powerful tools for raising awareness, building a passionate community, and driving real-world action for your cause. This guide will walk you through the essential steps to create an effective social media plan that generates results without burning out your team.
Start with Why: Define Your Social Media Goals
Before you post anything, you need to know what you’re trying to achieve. Likes and follows are nice, but for a nonprofit, social media needs to serve a greater purpose tied directly to your mission. Your goals will guide every decision you make, from the platforms you choose to the content you create.
The best way to set goals is by using the S.M.A.R.T. framework: Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. Vague goals like "get more donations" aren't helpful. Instead, a S.M.A.R.T. goal sounds like: "We will raise $5,000 for our back-to-school drive through Instagram and Facebook campaigns by the end of August."
Here are some common goals for nonprofit organizations:
- Raise awareness: Increase the number of people who know about your cause and your organization. A good metric here might be website traffic from social media or your social media reach.
- Drive donations: Encourage direct financial support. Track the number of donations and the total amount raised through specific social campaigns.
- Recruit volunteers: Inspire people to give their time. Measure this by tracking the number of volunteer applications that came from social channels.
- Educate the public: Inform your audience about the issues your organization addresses. Success could be measured by high engagement rates (shares and comments) on educational posts.
- Build a community: Create a loyal group of advocates and supporters. Track follower growth and engagement, especially comments and conversations.
Choose one or two primary goals to focus on at first. This will keep your strategy sharp and prevent you from feeling overwhelmed.
Know Who You’re Talking To: Understand Your Audience
You can't create content that connects with people if you don't know who they are. Your "audience" isn't everyone, it’s the specific group of people most likely to care about your mission. These are your current and potential donors, volunteers, partners, and advocates.
Start by creating simple audience personas. A persona is a semi-fictional character representing your ideal supporter. Give them a name, an age, and think about their daily life.
How to Build a Simple Persona:
- Demographics: What’s their age, location, and occupation?
- Interests: What do they care about besides your cause?
- Pain Points: What problem does your organization solve for them or for the world they care about?
- Online Behavior: Which social media platforms do they use most often? What kind of content do they like to share?
Example Persona: "Community Carol"
- Who she is: A 45-year-old high school teacher and mother of two who lives in the local community.
- Her interests: Local events, parenting blogs, and community improvement initiatives.
- Her online habits: She’s very active in local Facebook Groups and checks Instagram a few times a day to see photos from friends and community leaders.
- Why she cares: She wants her town to be a better place for her children to grow up in and believes in getting involved at the local level.
Now, when you create content, you can ask a simple question: "Would Community Carol find this interesting, inspiring, or useful?" This focus helps you stay on track.
Be Strategic: Choose the Right Platforms
Resist the urge to be active on every single social media platform. It's far more effective to do an amazing job on two channels than a mediocre job on six. Your audience personas are your guide here - go where your people already are.
A Quick Platform Breakdown for Nonprofits:
- Facebook: A cornerstone for many nonprofits. Excellent for building communities (through Facebook Groups), promoting events, sharing detailed stories, and reaching an older and more localized demographic. Facebook is also a powerhouse for fundraising.
- Instagram: This is a visual-first platform, perfect for showcasing your impact through powerful photos and videos. Instagram Reels (short-form video) are amazing for reaching new audiences, while Stories are great for offering a behind-the-scenes look at your work. It typically skews toward a younger audience (millennials and Gen Z).
- X (formerly Twitter): Best for real-time news, updates, and engaging in wider conversations. It's a great place to connect with journalists, other organizations, and elected officials. If you need to make quick announcements, X is your platform.
- LinkedIn: The professional network. Use it to connect with corporate partners, recruit board members and skilled volunteers, and share organizational milestones. It’s less about emotional storytelling and more about professional impact and partnerships.
- TikTok: The leader in short-form video. It offers incredible potential for a post to go viral and reach a massive, young audience. Nonprofits have found success here with educational content, personal stories, and participating in trends that align with their mission. It requires creativity and an understanding of the platform's culture.
- YouTube: The home of video. Perfect for longer-form content like mini-documentaries, volunteer training videos, event summaries, or in-depth explanations of your work. You can direct people here from other social media channels to tell a deeper story.
Plan Your Message: Craft Content That Resonates
Your content is the heart of your social media strategy. To avoid scratching your head every day wondering what to post, create a framework based on "content pillars." Content pillars are 3-5 core themes that you’ll rotate through. This ensures your content is varied, balanced, and always aligned with your goals.
Example Content Pillars for a Nonprofit:
- Pillar 1: Mission & Impact Stories. This is where you show, not just tell, the difference you make. Post photos of your work in action, share a glowing testimonial from someone you’ve helped, or create a short video summarizing the impact of a recent program. People connect with stories about people.
- Pillar 2: Educational Content. This builds your authority and informs your audience about the scope of the problem you're solving. Share a shocking statistic as a simple graphic, debunk a common myth related to your cause, or offer helpful tips for people who want to contribute in small ways.
- Pillar 3: Community & Culture. Pull back the curtain and show the humans behind your mission. A "Volunteer of the Month" spotlight, a "Day in the Life" of a staff member, or a thank you post for your donors - this content builds trust and forges a personal connection.
- Pillar 4: Advocacy & The "Ask." This pillar is reserved for your direct calls to action. It’s where you’ll run your fundraising campaigns, promote a petition, or ask people to sign up to volunteer. As a rule of thumb, only about one in every five posts should be a direct ask. The other four should be dedicated to giving value to your community. This 80/20 balance prevents your followers from feeling like you just see them as an ATM.
Engage, Don't Just Broadcast
Social media is a conversation, not a megaphone. Simply pushing out content and logging off is a missed opportunity. Building a community means engaging with the people who are taking the time to interact with you.
- Respond to comments and messages quickly. Acknowledge every thoughtful comment. If someone asks a question, answer it. This simple act shows you're listening and that you value your supporters.
- Ask questions. End your captions with open-ended questions to invite conversation. You could ask, "What part of our mission inspires you the most?" or "Share your favorite memory of volunteering with us!"
- Share user-generated content (UGC). If a volunteer posts a photo from your fundraising event and tags you, ask for their permission to reshare it. UGC is powerful social proof - it shows that real people are invested in your cause.
A strong community will champion your cause for you, sharing your posts and telling their friends about your work. That organic word-of-mouth is priceless.
Simplify Your Workflow: Use a Content Calendar
Consistency is the secret to social media success, but it's hard to be consistent when you're scrambling for ideas. A content calendar is your key to staying organized and saving time. It doesn't have to be complicated - a simple spreadsheet or calendar is all you need to get started.
Steps for Creating Your Calendar:
- Block out key dates. First, add important dates like Giving Tuesday, major holidays, awareness months relevant to your cause, and your own organization's anniversaries or events.
- Assign your content pillars. Use your pillars to fill in the days. For example, Monday could be a Mission & Impact story, Wednesday could be Educational content, and Friday could be a Community spotlight.
- Batch your content. Instead of trying to create a new post from scratch every single day, set aside a few hours once a week to do it all at once. Write all your captions for the week, create your graphics, and gather your photos and videos.
- Schedule your posts. Once you have your content ready, use a social media scheduling tool to load everything up. This allows you to "set it and forget it," freeing up your time to focus on engaging with your community in real-time.
Final Thoughts
Building a successful social media presence for your nonprofit is a marathon, not a sprint. By setting clear goals, understanding your audience, creating value-driven content, engaging with your community, and staying consistent, you can turn your social channels into a vital resource that helps you advance your mission and grow your impact.
Like many nonprofits, our team is stretched thin, so finding tools that simplify our workflow is game-changing. After using our calendar to map out our strategy, we rely on Postbase to schedule everything ahead of time. It lets us prepare and post content across all our major platforms from one place, which is especially helpful for planning out Reels and Shorts without juggling different apps. Plus, managing all comments and DMs in one inbox helps us stay connected with our community and saves us countless hours every week.
Spencer's spent a decade building products at companies like Buffer, UserTesting, and Bump Health. He's spent years in the weeds of social media management—scheduling posts, analyzing performance, coordinating teams. At Postbase, he's building tools to automate the busywork so you can focus on creating great content.