How to Post Old Facebook Posts to Instagram

You’ve got a goldmine of proven content sitting on your Facebook page, and it’s time to put it back to work on Instagram. Repurposing your old, high-performing Facebook posts is one of the smartest ways to keep your Instagram feed fresh and engaging without having to constantly brainstorm new ideas from scratch. This guide will walk you through exactly how to find your best old content, thoughtfully adapt it for Instagram’s unique audience, and post it in a way that feels brand new.

Why Bother Repurposing Old Facebook Posts?

Before jumping into the how-to, let's nail down the “why.” Recycling content isn't about being lazy, it's about being strategic. You're leveraging past successes to fuel future growth and working smarter, not harder.

It's a Massive Time and Energy Saver

Content creation is demanding. Coming up with original, high-quality ideas day after day can lead to burnout. By dipping into your archives, you already have a foundation to work from. The research is done, the core message is crafted, and you have proof that the topic resonates with an audience. This frees up your creative energy to focus on adaptation and optimization rather than starting from a blank page every single time.

Your Best Content Deserves a Second Life

It's a common mistake to think that if you posted something on Facebook, everyone who follows you has already seen it. The reality is that your Facebook followers and Instagram followers are often two distinct audiences, with some overlap. Even for those who follow you on both, social media feeds are so fast-moving that they likely missed your post the first time around. A post that sparked hundreds of comments and shares on Facebook has an incredible chance of performing well on Instagram when properly formatted. Don't let your greatest hits fade into obscurity.

You Can Test Instagram Concepts Without the Risk

Wondering if your audience is interested in behind-the-scenes content? Curious if a specific how-to guide would land well? Your old Facebook posts are a treasure trove of data. The posts with the highest engagement - the ones that got people talking, clicking, and sharing - give you a validated list of topics your audience cares about. Instead of guessing what might work on Instagram, you can confidently introduce themes and content pillars that are already proven winners.

How to Find Your Best-Performing Facebook Content

The first step is to become a content archaeologist, digging through your Facebook page to find the buried treasure. You're not looking for just any old post, you're looking for the evergreen gems that can shine again.

Step 1: Dig into Your Facebook Insights

Guesswork isn't part of the plan. You need data to pinpoint your strongest content. Your best tool for this is Meta Business Suite.

1. Go to your Meta Business Suite dashboard.
2. Navigate to the Insights tab on the left-hand menu.
3. Under Insights, click on Content.

Here, you'll see a breakdown of your recent posts. You can sort and filter this content based on key metrics. Don't just look at "Likes." You need a more sophisticated view:

• Reach: How many unique people saw your post? A high reach indicates the algorithm pushed it out widely.
• Engagements (Reactions, Comments, Shares): This is the most telling metric. High engagement, especially comments and shares, signals that your post sparked a conversation or provided enough value for someone to pass it along. This is gold dust.
• Link Clicks: If you shared a link to a blog or product, a high number of clicks means the headline and context were compelling enough to make people take action.

Look through your content from the last 6-12 months and identify the top 5-10 posts across these metrics. These are your primary candidates for repurposing.

Step 2: Filter for Timeless, Evergreen Content

Not everything that performed well is suitable for a second life. A post announcing a flash sale from last May or promoting a webinar that happened three months ago is no longer relevant. You need to focus on evergreen content - material that remains valuable and interesting indefinitely.

What to Look For:

• ✅ How-to Guides and Tutorials: Step-by-step instructions that solve a problem for your audience.
• ✅ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs): Answering a common question is always valuable.
• ✅ Customer Testimonials or Success Stories: Social proof never gets old.
• ✅ Behind-the-Scenes Looks: Showing how your product is made or introducing your team.
• ✅ Your Company's Mission or Values: Powerful statements that define your brand.
• ✅ Industry Tips and Tricks: Actionable advice that helps your audience.
• ✅ Inspiring Quotes or Stories: Content that connects on an emotional level.

What to Avoid:

• ❌ Old News or Time-Sensitive Announcements
• ❌ Expired Promotions, Sales, or Giveaways
• ❌ Announcements for Past Events
• ❌ Content Tied to a Dated Trend or Meme

Step 3: Organize Your Winners

Once you've identified your potential candidates, create a simple system to track them. A spreadsheet or a document works perfectly. Create columns for:

• Link to Original Facebook Post: For easy reference.
• Topic/Category: e.g., "Productivity Tip," "Customer Spotlight."
• Core Message: What's the one-sentence takeaway of the post?
• Potential Instagram Format: Start brainstorming here. "Could be a Carousel," "Good for a short Reel," "Perfect for a multi-slide Story."

This simple content library will become the foundation of your repurposing strategy and keep you from starting from scratch every time.

The Right Way to Adapt Facebook Posts for Instagram

This is where the magic happens. A simple copy-and-paste will fall flat. Instagram is a visually driven platform with its own culture and formatting quirks. A successful repurposed post feels native to Instagram, not like a visitor from another app.

Rethinking the Visuals

On Instagram, the visual does the heavy lifting. A standard landscape photo that looked fine on Facebook will get cropped awkwardly in the Instagram feed.

• From Text-Heavy Post to Carousel: Did you have a popular Facebook text-only post or one with a simple graphic explaining 5 tips? Turn it into an engaging multi-slide Instagram carousel. Use a tool like Canva to design clean, branded slides. The first slide should have a compelling title, and each subsequent slide can break down one tip. The final slide should have a clear call-to-action (CTA).
• From Single Image to an Experience: If the original post had just one horizontal photo, see if you can crop it to a 4:5 vertical portrait format, which takes up more screen real estate in the feed. Better yet, can you find 2-3 other related photos and create a photo-dump style carousel?
• From Long Video to Quick Reel: Have a 5-minute horizontal video that performed well on Facebook? That won't work for Reels. Your job is to extract the single most valuable piece of information - a 30-second tip, a quick tutorial, a satisfying product shot - and re-edit it into a vertical 9:16 video. Add text overlays and trending audio to make it feel native to the platform.

Rewriting the Caption

Instagram and Facebook captions serve different purposes and follow different rules.

• Break Up Your Text: Long, dense paragraphs that are common on Facebook are difficult to read on Instagram. Use line breaks (you can find-and-replace line-break generators online) to create white space. Sprinkle in relevant emojis to add personality and visual interest.
• Remove Outdated Links: Remember, clickable links don't work in Instagram captions. Any phrase like "Click here!" needs to be removed. Instead, direct people to the one place you can have a link: your bio. Change your CTA to something like, "Learn more through the link in our bio!"
• Master the Hashtag: Hashtags are footnotes on Facebook but are a core discovery engine on Instagram. Research and use a mix of hashtags: broad ones to reach a wide audience (e.g., #SocialMediaMarketing), niche ones to reach a targeted audience (e.g., #SmallBizMarketingTips), and branded ones for your business (e.g., #[YourBrandName]). Look for a sweet spot of 5-15 relevant hashtags.

Turning Blog Links into Engaging Stories

If your old Facebook post was simply a link to a blog article, you have a perfect opportunity to use Instagram Stories. Instead of just sharing a link, create a narrative.

1. Create Teaser Slides: Design 3-5 Story slides that summarize the most interesting points from the article. Use compelling photos or short video clips as the background.
2. Use Interactive Stickers: Engage your audience directly with poll stickers ("Have you tried this?"), quiz stickers, or question boxes ("What's your biggest challenge with X?").
3. Drive Traffic with the Link Sticker: On your final slide, use Instagram's link sticker to send people directly to the full blog post. This is a much more effective and engaging way to drive traffic than a non-clickable link in a feed post.

Putting It All Together: A Real-World Example

Let's imagine you run a small houseplant shop. You browse your Facebook Insights and find a post from six months ago that got tons of comments and shares.

The Original Post (Facebook)

• Image: A simple, horizontal photo of a thriving Fiddle Leaf Fig tree in someone's home.
• Text: A long paragraph explaining the top five reasons Fiddle Leaf Figs die (overwatering, not enough light, etc.) and asking people to share their own plant-care war stories in the comments. The post also included a link to your "Ultimate Plant Care" blog post.

Version 1: The Instagram Carousel Feed Post

• Visuals: A 6-slide carousel.
  • Slide 1: A beautiful, vertically cropped photo of a Fiddle Leaf Fig with a bold text overlay: "Are You Slowly Killing Your Fiddle Leaf Fig?"
  • Slides 2-5: Each slide addresses one common mistake (e.g., "Mistake #1: Too Much Love (aka Overwatering)") with a simple icon and a short line of text.
  • Slide 6: A compelling call-to-action: "Want to save your plants? Tap the link in our bio for the full guide."
• Caption: Something like: "We see it all the time. 🙈 The dreaded crispy brown leaves on a once-beautiful Fiddle Leaf Fig. Are you making one of these common mistakes? Swipe to find out! → Let us know in the comments which one you're guilty of! #FiddleLeafFig #HouseplantCare #PlantTips #IndoorJungle"

Version 2: The Instagram Reel

• Visuals: A quick, 15-second vertical video montage set to trending audio.
  • A shot of someone overwatering a plant.
  • A shot of a plant drooping in a dark corner.
  • A shot tipping the plant pot to show soggy roots.
  • A final shot of a thriving, happy plant in a brightly lit window.
• Text Overlay: Each clip has a text overlay with a simple message: "Killing your plants? // It’s probably one of these things... // Soggy roots // Not enough light // Tap the link in bio to become a plant pro!"
• Caption: Short and sweet, encouraging people to watch and then visit the link in bio.

Final Thoughts

Your existing Facebook page is an incredible resource waiting to be mined. By strategically finding your best evergreen content and thoughtfully adapting it for Instagram’s visual-first audience, you can create a consistent, high-quality content pipeline that saves you time and drives real engagement.

Repurposing content across multiple channels like this, especially when you’re creating Reels, carousels, and grid posts, can feel like a lot to juggle. This is exactly why we built Postbase - to cut through the chaos. With our visual calendar, you can map out your entire repurposed content schedule at a glance, drag and drop posts to see how they look, and then schedule them across every platform, including Reels and TikToks, without the tool fighting you. It helps you stay consistent without adding extra complexity back into your workflow.

```